Here is why I ask, and it isn’t for the reason you might expect.
Nearly everyone I speak with begins the same way: it came out of nowhere. One morning, one lift, one ordinary Tuesday, and then everything was different.
Sometimes that is exactly what happened, and I take people at their word. Bodies do occasionally turn a corner all at once.
But often, when there’s no hurry in the room and nobody is waiting for a tidy answer, something else surfaces. Ten or fifteen minutes in, a person will stop mid-sentence and say: actually — now that I think about it — I’d stopped taking the back stairs about a year before that. Or that she’d been sleeping on her other side since the spring. Or that she’d already quietly given up the garden two summers earlier and never once connected it to anything.
It isn’t that she was hiding it. It’s that it never looked like information. It looked like life, and like being sensible, and like getting on with things.
What that gives us isn’t blame. It’s context. It’s the difference between a story that begins on one bewildering Tuesday and a story that has a shape — a longer, gentler shape, in which your body was working around something for quite a while, competently, without making a fuss.
And a story with a shape is a much easier thing to be hopeful about than a story that begins with out of nowhere.